When a tax bill is more than you can pay
What to check, what to propose and when to speak to HMRC if a Self Assessment bill is more than you can pay now.
A tax bill that you cannot pay on the day it falls due is a cash problem with a deadline. Ignoring it does not freeze the interest or the letters. Paying it with the last of the money meant for suppliers or next month's costs, without a plan, can leave the business unable to earn the next bill. There is a middle path: work out what you can pay, say so early, and put the rest on a timetable you can meet.
This is general information, not a promise that a particular arrangement will be offered. HMRC decides on the facts, and the process changes. Check current guidance, and get advice if the amount is large or several debts are involved.
Look at the figure before you look at the fear
Read the calculation. Separate income tax, National Insurance and any payment on account. Check it against your own profit. A bill that feels impossible is sometimes a bill that includes an advance towards next year, as described in payments on account. If the profit was genuinely lower, there may be a route to reduce that advance. If the calculation is simply right, the problem is funding, not arithmetic.
Also check you have filed. A return still outstanding and a payment still outstanding are two conversations. Filing, even when you cannot pay in full, stops one of them growing.
Build a short cash picture
Write what is in the bank, what must leave in the next month for costs that keep the work going, and what invoices are realistically due. The twelve-week forecast is the right shape. Do not offer a monthly sum that only works if every client pays early and you take no drawings. An offer you will break is worse than a smaller offer you will keep.
Include other debts honestly: a loan, a card, rent you are behind on. An arrangement that ignores them collapses in the second month. This is also a moment to pause non-essential spending, with the same eye as a cost review.
Talk before the due date
Contact HMRC as soon as you know you cannot pay in full, ideally before the deadline. Explain what you can pay now and the timetable for the rest. There is a well-known type of arrangement, often called Time to Pay, but whether you are offered one depends on your circumstances and on the current process. Do not rely on a blog for a phone number or a form. Use the details on the letter or on the official HMRC pages.
Have your tax reference, the amount and your cash picture to hand. A specific proposal is easier to discuss than a general sense that the figure is too big.
Do not fund the bill in a way that hides it
A personal credit card or a loan from family can be a bridge. It can also move the debt somewhere you stop looking at it, often at a higher cost, while the business carries on as if the tax were sorted. If you borrow, write the repayment beside your drawings and make it visible in the budget. Questions about borrowing deserve a calm hour, not the night before the deadline.
Do not stop trading and stop communicating at the same time. A business that can still invoice is more likely to clear the bill than one that has gone silent.
After you agree a plan, fund it weekly
Whatever timetable you are given, or that you set while you wait, move money towards it in ordinary weeks. A tax pot that fell short needs a more frequent transfer, not a more hopeful speech. Lower the drawing until the arrangement and the new set-aside can coexist. If a later month slips, contact HMRC again before the missed instalment, not after a string of them.
Then ask why the pot was short. The answer is usually in the records: profit higher than you admitted during the year, or cash taken as if tax were optional. Fix that cause, or the next January will look the same.
Frequently asked questions
Will an arrangement cost more? Interest can continue on unpaid tax, and the terms are HMRC's. An arrangement is usually less damaging than ignoring the debt. Compare it with the cost of other borrowing rather than assuming it is free.
Should I pay suppliers or the tax first? There is no universal order. Costs that stop you earning can make the tax harder to finish. Take advice if you cannot see a way to honour both over time. Do not simply pay whoever is loudest.
What if I disagree with the amount? Use the route on the letter, with your workings. A dispute is not the same as an inability to pay. If both are true, explain both. Silence covers neither.
Steps
- Read the calculation and file if you have not: Separate the balancing payment from any payment on account. Filing and paying are different duties.
- Write a twelve-week picture you can keep: Include essential costs and realistic invoices. Offer a sum the business can actually transfer.
- Contact HMRC before the due date: Use the details on their letter or official pages. Have your reference, the amount and your proposal ready.
- Fund the plan in ordinary weeks: Lower drawings if needed, and call again before you miss an instalment. Then fix the set-aside habit that fell short.