Bookkeeping Software or a Spreadsheet: Which Should You Choose?
Compare spreadsheets and accounting software for small business bookkeeping: costs, effort, features and signs that it may be time to switch.
Sooner or later every small business owner faces the question: should I keep my books in a spreadsheet, or use accounting software? There is no single right answer. The best tool is the one that fits your size, your skills and the time you can give it. This article compares the two approaches so you can choose with confidence.
The case for a spreadsheet
A spreadsheet is familiar, flexible and usually free or very cheap. For a sole trader with a small number of transactions each month, it can be perfectly adequate. A simple layout with columns for date, description, category, money in and money out is enough to track income and expenses and to produce totals at the end of the year.
The main advantages are:
- Low cost: You may already own the software.
- Full control: You can design the layout to suit your needs.
- Easy to understand: There is nothing hidden, so it is a good way to learn how bookkeeping works.
The drawbacks are just as real:
- Manual work: Every entry is typed or pasted in, which takes time.
- Risk of errors: A mistyped formula or a deleted row can go unnoticed.
- Limited reporting: Invoicing, reminders and tax summaries must be done by hand or with separate tools.
- Version control: Keeping several copies can lead to confusion.
The case for accounting software
Online accounting packages are designed for the job. They typically connect to your bank account and import transactions automatically, allow you to match them to invoices and receipts, create and send invoices, and produce reports such as profit and loss. Many include tools to help you prepare tax information.
The benefits include:
- Time saving: Bank feeds reduce typing.
- Fewer mistakes: Automatic calculations and checks help accuracy.
- Better records: Receipts can be attached to transactions, which is useful if you are asked to support your figures.
- Useful reports: You can see your income, costs and tax position at any time.
The downsides are a monthly subscription, a learning curve and, for some, a feeling of less control. Prices and features vary widely, so compare carefully and take advantage of free trials where they are offered.
Digital record keeping and tax
HMRC has been moving towards digital record keeping and reporting for more taxpayers, and the rules and timetable have changed over time. Check the current requirements on GOV.UK to see whether they apply to you, as this can influence your choice of tool. Some spreadsheets can be used with bridging software, while many accounting packages already support the relevant processes.
Questions to ask yourself
- How many transactions do I have each month?
- Do I invoice customers regularly and need to track who has paid?
- How comfortable am I with technology?
- Do I work with an accountant who prefers a particular system?
- Am I likely to grow or take on staff soon?
If you have few transactions and enjoy a hands-on approach, a spreadsheet is a sensible start. If you are spending hours on admin or struggling to keep track of invoices, software may pay for itself.
Making the move
If you decide to switch, pick a sensible start date, such as the beginning of a tax year or month, and import your opening balances carefully. Keep your old spreadsheet safe for reference. Whatever tool you choose, the principles in our bookkeeping for beginners guide still apply: record promptly, keep evidence and reconcile with your bank. Separating your finances, as discussed in our article on business and personal money, makes either option easier.
This article gives general information and is not financial advice.
Frequently asked questions
Is free software good enough? Some free options are fine for simple needs, but check their limits and what happens if you outgrow them.
Will my accountant mind which I use? Many accountants work with several systems, but ask them first, as the right choice can save you both time.
Can I move from a spreadsheet to software later? Yes. Most packages let you import data, though it is wise to start cleanly from a defined date.