What bank feeds do well and what they miss
What a bank feed does well, what it cannot know, and why you still reconcile to the statement each month.
A bank feed pulls transactions into bookkeeping software so you type less. It is a genuine saving on a busy month. It is also easy to treat as finished bookkeeping. The feed does not know which client a payment belongs to, whether a receipt was personal, or that a transfer between your own accounts is not income. Those decisions stay yours.
If you are still choosing a tool, the wider comparison is in software or a spreadsheet. A feed is a feature, not the whole decision.
What a feed is good at
It is good at collecting the dates and amounts the bank already knows, without mis-keying a figure. It is good at suggesting a match when an amount equals an invoice you have already raised. It is good at making a weekly look less daunting, because the lines are already on the screen. Used that way, it supports the reconciliation rather than replacing it.
It is also useful as a prompt. A line you do not recognise is more visible when it is waiting to be categorised than when it is one of two hundred on a PDF you meant to open.
What it does not know
The feed cannot tell sales from a loan, a tax refund, or money you transferred in from savings. If you accept the suggestion "income" for all three, profit swells. It cannot split a shop receipt between materials and a personal item. It cannot know that two invoices of the same amount are different clients. Blind acceptance is how the books look complete and are wrong.
It also does not hold your receipts. A categorised line without a document is a weaker record than a slower line with the invoice attached. The standard in what to record and why still applies. The feed is the list. The receipt is the evidence.
Delays, duplicates and missing days
Feeds can lag. A payment that has cleared may not appear until the next day, or longer. Do not panic, and do not enter it by hand and then accept the feed as well. Duplicates are the classic result. If you add a manual line, match it when the feed arrives rather than leaving both.
Feeds can also stop without a dramatic error, after a password change or a bank update. Check that the latest date on the feed is recent before you trust a month-end. A silent gap looks like a quiet week. It may be a broken connection.
Rules are helpful and dangerous
A rule that always categorises a known supplier as materials can save minutes. A rule that categorises every incoming payment as sales will eventually swallow a refund or a personal transfer. Review the rules twice a year. If you cannot explain a rule in a sentence, turn it off and categorise those lines yourself.
Suggestions are not rules. Look at the ones the software is least sure about. That is where the interesting mistakes sit. The confident ones can still be wrong, especially when amounts repeat.
Keep a human month end
Once a month, reconcile to the statement, not to the feed's idea of the balance. They should agree. If they do not, the feed is missing or duplicating something. Tick outstanding invoices separately, so a matched bank line is not confused with a sale you have only hoped for.
Then read the profit and loss for anything absurd: negative costs, income that equals the entire bankings including transfers, a tax payment sat in sales. Those are feed habits showing through. Five minutes of disbelief will find them. A year of unexamined acceptance will not.
A feed is a good assistant. It is a poor accountant. You remain the person who decides what the line means.
Frequently asked questions
If I have a feed, do I still need statements? Yes. Download them and keep them. The feed can change provider, and the statement is the bank's record. Your return may need the statement long after the feed has forgotten the year.
Can a feed code my VAT? It can apply the settings you gave it. If the settings are wrong, the VAT is wrong at scale. Check the tax code on anything unusual, and do not assume a new supplier inherited the right rate.
Is a feed safe? It is a connection you authorise, with the risks of any such link. Use the provider your software expects, review access, and disconnect accounts you no longer use. Do not hand your login to a person who offers to set it up by email.