Card disputes and what to keep on file
What a card chargeback does to your cash, which records help, and how to respond to the notice without missing the date.
A chargeback is a card payment that the customer's bank reverses after a dispute. The money leaves your account, often with a fee, and you may be asked for evidence that you delivered what was paid for. It is unsettling, and it is also a process with a file attached. How you respond depends on the card provider's rules and on the facts. This article is the habit of keeping that file, not a script that wins every dispute.
It is general information. Schemes and time limits differ. Read the notice you were sent and follow that timetable.
Why the money can leave after you were paid
Card payments are not the same as a cleared bank transfer. The customer can tell their bank that the charge was unauthorised, that the goods or service did not arrive, or that it was not as described. The bank can then pull the funds back while the dispute is looked at. You may win the funds back if your evidence is enough under the scheme's rules. You may not. The fee you pay to accept cards is only the visible cost. A reversal is the other part of the bargain, and it belongs in the decision to offer cards at all.
A transfer has its own problems. It does not have this particular one. Know which tool you used for the job.
What to keep before anyone complains
Keep the quote or the terms the client accepted, the invoice, the proof of delivery or of the session that took place, and the messages in which they agreed the scope. A card receipt on its own shows that a card was charged. It does not show that you did the work. The invoice and the written acceptance are the heart of the file.
For goods, keep dispatch details. For a service, keep the date, what was delivered, and any sign-in or confirmation. Store them where you can find them without reconstructing the job from memory. Disputes arrive later than the glow of the payment.
What to do when the notice arrives
Read the deadline on the notice first. Missing it can lose the argument regardless of the facts. Gather the file and send what the notice asks for, through the route it gives you, not through a random email address. Stick to the documents. A long story about the client's character is weaker than the quote and the delivery proof.
Do not spend the disputed sum as if it were settled, even if it is still in the account while you reply. Treat it as money that might leave. Your cash forecast should show it as uncertain until the outcome is known.
Patterns are a business issue
One dispute can be a misunderstanding. Several, on the same kind of job, are a clue: unclear descriptions, a delivery problem, or a payment taken before the client understood the fee. Look at the quote and at the moment you take the card payment. Surprising a client with a charge is a common path into a dispute. So is a refund process so slow that the client asks their bank instead of you.
Offer a clear way to ask for a refund. Some disputes exist because the customer could not reach a human. A refund you choose, recorded properly, is often less damaging than a chargeback you fight and lose, though that judgement depends on the case.
Keep the books honest either way
If the money goes and does not return, record the reversal against the sale, not as a vague expense, and record any fee as a fee. If you later win, record the money coming back against the same sale so you do not create a new ghost invoice. The trail should show one job, disputed, and an outcome.
Then decide whether that type of card payment is still worth offering. A tool that brings speed and occasional reversals can still be right. It should be a choice you review, not a shock you meet for the first time with an empty folder.
Frequently asked questions
Can I refuse card payments to avoid chargebacks? Yes. Many sole traders take only transfers. You may lose some convenience. You gain a firmer receipt. Choose with your clients and your margins in view.
Should I refund as soon as a dispute starts? Not automatically. Read the notice. Sometimes a prompt refund is the sensible end. Sometimes you have delivered and the evidence is strong. Decide from the file, and do not ignore the deadline while you decide.
Does a signed contract guarantee I will win? No. It helps, and the scheme's rules still decide. A contract no one can find does not help at all. Keep the acceptance with the payment.